Lisa Duran booked two repair services for the same flat tire, from the same parking lot. The first missed two appointments without calling. The second quoted 60 to 90 minutes, and its technician called when he was 15 minutes out, then arrived as promised.
Duran and her husband were driving a Class A RV south from South Dakota on Interstate 29 when potholes knocked a tire partly off the bead. They did not feel it happen. They found it nearly flat after pulling into the Elks Lodge parking lot in Blue Springs, Missouri, outside Kansas City, looking for level ground. They had two dogs aboard, and her husband was recovering from a stroke.
The vehicle was a motorhome, not a tractor, but the question it raised is one every fleet puts to a repair vendor: what a promised arrival time is worth, and what happens when it slips.
Key Findings
- Two vendors took calls about the same failure from the same parking lot. What separated them was communication, not capability or price.
- The first company missed an afternoon appointment and an 8 a.m. appointment the next morning, without a call either time. Its callback came 15 minutes after Duran canceled.
- The second quoted a 60-to-90-minute window. The technician called within the hour to say he was about 15 minutes away, then arrived as stated.
- The technician's inspection confirmed what her husband had found: a tire partly off the bead, with no damage to the rim.
- The points that decided this comparison apply to any repair vendor a fleet buys from: a specific window, a call before the customer has to ask, and an accurate report of what failed.
The First Call: Two Missed Appointments
Duran found the first company the way buyers often find a vendor under time pressure: a search, a set of reviews, a phone number. "He had some pretty good reviews, so I called him and scheduled the appointment," she said.
No one arrived that afternoon, and no one called. The company promised a technician at 8 a.m. the next morning. No one arrived then either, again without a call, and Duran left a voicemail and a text canceling the job.
"Fifteen minutes after I cancel, he calls and says he's on the way," Duran said.
Roadside work runs late for ordinary reasons: a previous job turns into something larger, a part is wrong, traffic backs up. The delay alone did not decide it. Without an update, Duran could not tell whether the technician was 10 minutes out or not coming, so she had no basis for choosing between waiting and starting over. She started over.
An ETA given at booking, with nothing in place to revise it, stops being useful information as soon as it slips. The company's update arrived after the decision it could have informed.
The Second Call: A Window and a Call Ahead
Duran searched again, with less confidence than the first time, and found Truckup, a mobile truck repair service in Kansas City. She had one specific doubt.
"I wasn't really sure about Truckup, because it seemed to be more like it was for semis than RVs," she said.
She called anyway and asked the dispatcher, David, whether they did RV tires. He said yes and quoted a window of 60 to 90 minutes. "Very helpful, very clear communicator," Duran said of him.
A specific window gives the buyer something to plan against. Duran had a fallback if this call also failed, and it was expensive: "Keep calling around and just change our plans to have to stay there longer." The window told her when she would know whether she needed it.
Jerrell, the technician, called within the hour to say he was about 15 minutes away, and arrived when he said he would. The range David quoted is the same one George, who works Truckup's dispatch desk alongside him, describes using on purpose: "If one of my guys says 60 minutes, I like to say 60 to 90, just to give a little breathing room in case of a traffic jam, an accident, or bad weather."
What the Technician Found
Jerrell spent about an hour and a half on the repair. Duran's husband wanted to help, and Jerrell found him things to do.
"He was just really friendly," Duran said. "He was empathetic... he was open to let my husband help a little."
Her husband had already found the tire partly off the bead. Jerrell's inspection confirmed it and found no damage to the rim, so the wheel did not need replacing. "That was good news," Duran said.
At the roadside, a customer often has no practical way to check a diagnosis, no second opinion nearby, and little leverage to walk away, so the vendor's finding largely sets the scope of the job and the bill. Jerrell's finding matched what her husband had already seen.
What Carries Over to Fleet Vendor Service
Duran does not run a fleet. She and her husband are experienced RV travelers who have been through breakdowns before, so her comparison rests on more than one bad experience.
The dispatcher she reached handles fleet accounts in the same market. Kea Wanamaker, a WillScot fleet manager in Kansas City, texts him directly when one of her trucks goes down.
Ranking the company against the repair services she has used, Duran put it "at the top of the list." "Excellent customer service. Stand by their word," she said.
Duran posted a review the same day: "We're back on the road travelling 200 miles today with no problems."
.png)
.avif)
